@uzbyuksalish

Telegram

@uzbyuksalish

en

Managing Multi-Storey Housing: Public Perspectives and Key Issues

 2025-05-07 11:45:31   |     Просмотров: 5927

In accordance with the Presidential Decree of the Republic of Uzbekistan dated June 19, 2021, titled “On Further Improvement of the Management System of Multi-Apartment Residential Buildings”, extensive efforts have been carried out across the country to renovate multi-apartment buildings and enhance the adjacent areas.

Currently, there are 42,072 multi-apartment buildings in the country, comprising over 1.4 million residential units. Of these, 38,689 buildings are serviced by 821 management service companies, 849 buildings by 157 homeowners’ associations, 676 buildings are managed directly by property owners, and 1,405 buildings are maintained by various institutions and organizations.

In February 2025, Yuksalish Movement conducted a comprehensive study to assess the management of multi-apartment buildings, the performance of management service companies, and public perception of the system.

The study analyzed the management status of 371 residential buildings across the country, along with the operations of 109 management service companies (hereinafter referred to as MSCs).

Additionally, a sociological survey was conducted among 2,340 respondents to assess consumer satisfaction with the services provided by MSCs.

The research revealed a number of issues in the management of multi-apartment buildings that have been a source of concern and dissatisfaction among residents.

A recent assessment has revealed multiple shortcomings in the management of multi-apartment residential buildings across Uzbekistan, particularly concerning the quality and consistency of services provided by Management Service Companies (MSCs).

Of the 52 buildings examined, basements in 16 were found to be either inadequately serviced or entirely neglected by the assigned MSCs, resulting in the accumulation of waste and unsanitary conditions. Furthermore, 34 buildings exhibited serious deterioration of their façades due to the failure of 18 MSCs to carry out routine maintenance and repairs.

As part of the monitoring process, residents were interviewed to gather feedback on the performance of management companies. In 112 buildings and their surrounding areas, residents expressed justified dissatisfaction due to the lack of landscaping and maintenance work by the MSCs. Notably, this issue was especially prevalent in Kashkadarya (32 buildings, 7 MSCs), Jizzakh (23 buildings, 3 MSCs), Surkhandarya (12 buildings, 5 MSCs), and Andijan (12 buildings, 2 MSCs), where no improvement or beautification efforts were being carried out.

According to a nationwide survey, 35.8% of respondents rated the performance of MSCs as unsatisfactory.

The study also highlighted a systemic issue: homeowners are often not given the right to freely choose their preferred method of housing management. This contradicts Article 4 of the Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On Protection of Consumer Rights”, which guarantees consumers the freedom to choose goods and services and demand their quality.

In practice, once a management structure is selected for a building, property owners are frequently excluded from the decision-making process in choosing a specific MSC. This has led to various conflicts between MSCs and homeowners, including refusal to sign bilateral contracts, non-payment of mandatory fees, substandard or incomplete service delivery, and the collection of fees for services that were not rendered.

Additionally, in several cases, individual MSCs have been assigned to service over 100 residential buildings, far exceeding their operational capacity. For instance, in Urgench, “Khorezm Shinam Uylar” LLC manages 307 buildings; in Asaka district, “Bio Tech Service” LLC handles 172; in Samarkand, “Samarkand Oltin Asr” LLC is responsible for 167; in Kogon, “Bakhshullo Kamoliddin” LLC manages 131; and in Termez, “Sarvar Termiz Service” LLC is assigned 124 buildings.

Interviews with residents of buildings serviced by these MSCs revealed that many property owners were not even aware of which company was managing their building. Moreover, they reported being charged maintenance fees without receiving any corresponding services.

Further concerns were raised during an online roundtable held in Tashkent with industry experts involved in housing management. Participants reported that certain actions by local government representatives—often unlawful or inappropriate—are contributing to serious sectoral problems. These issues are negatively affecting public sentiment, and residents’ formal complaints have so far gone unaddressed.

One of the key findings of the study revealed serious public concerns over the process by which multi-apartment buildings are being assigned to management service companies (MSCs) without the consent of property owners or competitive selection procedures, in violation of existing legal norms.

In particular, documents submitted by independent experts indicate that, in 2024 alone, the Yashnobod District Administration unilaterally assigned 1,096 buildings to MSCs based on just eight administrative statements; the Mirzo Ulugbek District Administration did the same with 17 buildings; and the Yunusabad District Administration handed over 115 buildings through only two such statements — all without conducting open tenders, as required by law.

Moreover, there is growing evidence of pressure exerted by local authorities on homeowners’ associations (HOAs) to transfer building management responsibilities to MSCs, undermining the autonomy of property owners. This is being done under the so-called “one neighborhood – one management company” approach, often imposed without considering the will of residents and interpreted by many as administrative interference serving the interests of MSCs rather than the community.

Further concerns include the widespread failure of many MSCs to comply with legal requirements regarding the setting of mandatory service fees and the lack of transparency in reporting service delivery to residents. According to current regulations, MSCs are required to provide biannual reports to homeowners on fee collection and building maintenance expenses. However, numerous complaints have been received from residents who report not receiving any such updates.

An anonymous survey conducted among property owners helped shed additional light on these issues. When asked how quickly MSCs respond to resident complaints, only 26.6% said their issues were addressed within one week. Meanwhile, 17.4% reported that resolution took a month or longer, and another 17.4% stated they received no response at all.

Regarding the overall impact of MSC involvement, 30.8% of respondents said there had been no noticeable improvement since the company took over management, and 16.9% reported receiving no services whatsoever.

Participants also voiced suggestions for improving the quality and scope of services provided. Among them, 46.1% highlighted the need for better landscaping and greener public spaces, while 45.7% advocated for the installation of video surveillance in public areas to enhance safety.

Notably, 44% of respondents stated that mandatory monthly fees were set without consultation with property owners, and 14.7% reported that high fees were imposed despite their objections. Furthermore, 27.1% expressed frustration over being charged fees despite receiving no services, and 24.1% said the prices charged were not reflective of the quantity or quality of services provided.

The analysis underscores that, despite ongoing reforms in the housing management sector, key issues persist in the performance of MSCs — including limited efficiency, lack of accountability, and poor service quality. Among the most critical concerns are the restriction of homeowners’ right to freely choose their management model, insufficient transparency in MSC operations, and unwarranted interference by local authorities. These issues risk undermining public confidence in the reform process and in the future of effective, community-driven housing management.

To address the current challenges and improve the management of multi-apartment residential buildings, the following key measures are proposed:

  • Ensuring the direct involvement of property owners in the selection of management service companies (MSCs);
  • Establishing a cap on the number of residential buildings that a single MSC can service, to prevent overload and ensure quality;
  • Introducing an effective oversight mechanism to monitor whether MSCs possess the necessary resources, equipment, and qualified personnel to provide high-quality services;
  • Developing a unified online platform to fully digitize the interaction between MSCs and property owners—enabling transparent communication, community engagement, and public evaluation of service providers;
  • Abolishing the practice of setting minimum mandatory monthly service fees for property owners and transitioning to a system based on free-market principles.

In addition, it is recommended that the State Inspection for Supervision in the Field of Construction and Housing and Communal Services, in cooperation with city and district administrations, conduct a comprehensive review of all active MSCs. Based on this assessment—and with input from the public—concrete proposals should be developed to resolve systemic issues.

To effectively tackle the identified challenges, it is essential to uphold the rule of law, implement transparent and accountable governance mechanisms that protect residents' interests, strengthen the financial and institutional capacity of MSCs, and adopt international best practices where applicable.