@uzbyuksalish

Telegram

@uzbyuksalish

en

Is It Correct to Establish a Separate Norm On Discrediting Law Enforcement Officers?

 2023-12-01 15:02:57   |     Просмотров: 3926

A draft law imposing a fine of 50 times the amount of the basic calculation value, or 15 days of administrative imprisonment for posting photos and video images on the Internet information network with the purpose of discrediting or insulting the employees of law enforcement agencies, proposed by the Ministry of Internal Affairs, passed in the third reading yesterday in the Legislative Chamber of the Oliy Majlis. The law caused a broad response and objections among the public.

The public insists that the introduction of this norm contradicts today's policy of openness and may undermine the state of human rights in the country.

The Nationwide Movement "Yuksalish" considers these objections to be valid for the following reasons:

First, every change in the legislation, especially the introduction of a new rule that seriously affects the policy regarding human rights, openness, and transparency of state bodies, which are the main characteristics of democracy, should have certain grounds.

That is, today, are there too many cases of unjustified discrediting and insulting of law enforcement officers on the Internet? If increased, what are the exact numbers? What is the reason, and how serious are these conditions for the healthy functioning of the system? Of course, these questions must be answered.

Secondly, in order to justify this norm, Article 99 of the Civil Code and Articles 4 and 28 of the Law "On Personal Information" are given as a basis.

For information: According to these articles, a person's life and health, honor and dignity, privacy, professional reputation, privacy, private and family secrets, the right to name, the right to an image, copyright, other personal property rights, and other immaterial benefits belonging to a citizen from birth or according to the law cannot be taken away and cannot be transferred to another person in any other way (Article 99).

At the same time, it is stipulated that the disclosure and distribution of personal information without the subject's consent or other legal basis are not allowed.

Information relating to a specific individual or enabling his identification, recorded electronically, on paper, and/or in another material body, is considered personal data (Article 4).

However, the legislation has already established sanctions for violations in this regard. That is, there is administrative and criminal liability for insulting a person. In addition, according to Article 2022 of the Code of Administrative Responsibility, spreading false information, including in the mass media, telecommunications, or Internet networks, which leads to the humiliation of a person's dignity or his discredit, will result in a fine of 50 times the base calculation amount.

Dissemination of false information threatening public order or security, including dissemination in mass media, telecommunications, or Internet networks, shall result in fines ranging from 50 to 100 times the base calculation amount.

Therefore, why is there a need for a special norm aimed at law enforcement officers? Today, human rights and interests are placed at the center of state administration. This idea is reflected in the principle of "individual-society-state" as the main criteria of the updated Constitution. It cannot be the other way around.

Thirdly, the experiences of countries such as Great Britain, Hungary, Germany, France, and Belarus were studied in the implementation of this norm. But it is necessary to analyze in depth the nature of socio-political problems in these countries and the situations in which such norms are used.

The listed and other developed democratic countries, of course, have such restrictions, but in these countries, every citizen is guaranteed the right to obtain the records of a police officer's body camera in conflict situations.

Fourthly, according to the law "On the Openness of Activities of State Power and Management Bodies", transparency and the freedom to seek, receive, and distribute information about the activities of state agencies are set as the main principles of the openness of the activities of state bodies.

The determination of the new responsibility introduced by the new norm should not lead to the rule that it is not possible to film the activities of law enforcement officers in connection with their service.

Fifth, on the other hand, when images of law enforcement agency misconduct are circulated on the Internet, leaders should focus on improving the system. This serves to increase the professionalism of law enforcement agencies.

The Nationwide Movement "Yuksalish" supports changes in the law to ensure road safety, especially pedestrian safety. At the same time, the law will be considered by the Senate of the Oliy Majlis. At this stage, we believe that senators should pay serious attention to the questions and objections raised by the public.

Press service of the Nationwide Movement "Yuksalish".